Top 5 Underrated Caribbean Island Destinations
The Caribbean is known for its turquoise waters, white sandy beaches, and vibrant culture. While destinations like the Bahamas and the Dominican Republic are a quick flight from the U.S., and often steal the spotlight for inexpensive Caribbean destinations, there are hidden gems that offer equally stunning experiences without overwhelming crowds. Here are our Weather Passport reader’s Top 5 underrated Caribbean islands you should consider for your next tropical escape.
1. Grand Cayman, Cayman Islands
While many travelers flock to Grand Cayman for its luxurious resorts and famous Seven Mile Beach, there’s so much more to explore. Beyond the popular tourist spots, you’ll find incredible snorkeling opportunities right off the shore. Several of the hotels and resorts have created man-made reefs which attract colorful fish. If you stay near Seven Mile Beach, you’ll have easy access to marine life and pristine waters. Don’t miss out on a visit to Stingray City and Starfish Point for a truly unique experience interacting with local sea creatures. And for a fun day out, the Cayman Turtle Center offers an educational encounter with turtles of all sizes.
Must-Do:
- Snorkel directly from the beach for stunning underwater views.
- Visit Georgetown for shopping and dining with a local flair.
- Check out Camana Bay’s lively atmosphere for dinner and entertainment.
2. Negril, Jamaica
While Montego Bay and Ocho Rios are household names, Negril offers a more laid-back vibe perfect for relaxation. Famous for its seven miles of white sandy beaches, Negril is the ideal spot for sunset lovers. The town is known for its vibrant reggae culture, cliff diving at Rick’s Cafe, and authentic Jamaican cuisine.
Must-Do:
- Watch the sunset from the cliffs at Rick’s Cafe. [Check out Live Cam]
- Explore the coral reefs while snorkeling or scuba diving.
- Experience live reggae music at one of the local beach bars.
3. St. Thomas, U.S. Virgin Islands
St. Thomas is often overshadowed by its neighboring island, St. John, but it has plenty to offer. From breathtaking viewpoints to world-class snorkeling, it’s a paradise for adventure seekers and beach lovers alike. One hidden gem is Magens Bay, where you can snorkel with sea turtles if you’re lucky. The island’s vibrant shopping scene in Charlotte Amalie adds to the charm.
Must-Do:
- Snorkel at Magens Bay and try to spot the friendly sea turtles.
- Take a scenic tram ride to Paradise Point for panoramic island views.
- Enjoy duty-free shopping in Charlotte Amalie.
4. Bequia, St. Vincent and the Grenadines
Bequia is a small island bursting with character and charm. Known for its relaxed atmosphere and friendly locals, it’s perfect for travelers looking to escape the crowds. The island features beautiful beaches, scenic hikes, and vibrant coral reefs. It’s also a sailor’s paradise, attracting yachts from around the world.
Must-Do:
- Visit Princess Margaret Beach for a peaceful day by the water.
- Go snorkeling or diving at the Devil’s Table reef.
- Explore the Old Hegg Turtle Sanctuary.
5. Saba, Caribbean Netherlands
If you’re looking for something truly unique, Saba is the place to go. Often called the “Unspoiled Queen” of the Caribbean, this small volcanic island is known for its rugged landscapes, hiking trails, and world-class scuba diving. With no sandy beaches, Saba attracts travelers looking for adventure and nature.
Must-Do:
- Hike to the top of Mount Scenery, the highest point in the Dutch Kingdom.
- Explore the island’s diverse marine life through scuba diving.
- Visit Windwardside for quaint shops and local eateries.
Final Thoughts
These underrated Caribbean islands offer unforgettable experiences without the overwhelming crowds. Whether you’re seeking adventure, relaxation, or cultural immersion, each destination has something unique to offer. So pack your bags, bring along the right travel gear, and get ready to discover the hidden gems of the Caribbean.
Are you planning a trip to any of these islands? Let me know in the comments!