Tour The Most Beautiful Car-Free Island in America since 1898
Mackinac Island is literally like stepping into a storybook. We knew it was going to be special when were were taking the ferry over from Mackinac City. As soon as we arrived, the absence of cars made it so peaceful. The classic charm of horse-drawn carriages clip-clopping down the cobblestone streets. The families riding their bicycles together down the street. There’s something magical about exploring a place where time seems to have paused.
If you’re planning a visit, here’s everything you need to know to make the most of your trip, from biking around the island to indulging in its famous fudge.
Biking Around Mackinac Island: Freedom on Two Wheels
One of the best ways to explore Mackinac Island is by bike. With no cars allowed, the island is a cyclist’s paradise. I rented my bike from Mackinac Wheels, a friendly and well-stocked shop that had everything from tandem bikes to electric-assisted options. If you’re traveling with kids, they also have trailers and tag-along bikes.
Many Mackinac Island bike rental shops offer rates by the hour, by the day or per 24 hours. Rates are roughly $15 per hour and range from about $50 to $100 per day, depending on the kind of bike. Electric wheelchairs and e-scooters tend to rent at the upper end of these price ranges.
The 8-mile loop around the island is a must-do. The smooth, scenic path hugs the coastline, offering breathtaking views of Lake Huron. It took Vicky and I about two hours to complete the loop at a leisurely pace, with plenty of stops for photos and a picnic by Arch Rock. If you’re feeling adventurous, take one of the inland trails through the Mackinac Island State Park, where the forest canopy provides a cool escape from the sun. There are one or two places to get some snacks along the way.
Pro Tip: Start your ride early in the morning to avoid the crowds and enjoy the serene beauty of the island before the day-trippers arrive.
Horse and Carriage Tour: Stepping Back in Time
I couldn’t leave without experiencing the iconic horse and carriage tour. It felt like traveling back to the 19th century as we trotted past the historic Victorian mansions. Our guide was knowledgeable and had a great sense of humor, sharing fascinating stories about the island’s past.
The tour took us through Fort Mackinac, perched high on the bluffs with stunning panoramic views, and then through the peaceful lanes of the State Park. It was the perfect way to learn about the island’s history while relaxing in the shade of the carriage canopy.
Pro Tip: Book your carriage tour early in the day or late afternoon for a quieter, more relaxed experience.
While we had seen Arch Rock from below on our bike trek around the island, the carriage tour stopped at the top so we could see the beautiful blue Lake Huron in the distance.
Why So Much Fudge?
Mackinac Island is known as the Fudge Capital of the World, and the sweet scent hits you the moment you step off the ferry. But why so many fudge shops? It turns out the tradition started in the late 19th century when tourists began visiting the island. The fudge makers seized the opportunity to entertain them by crafting their confections right in front of the shop windows. The rest is delicious history.
During my visit, I sampled my way through Murdick’s, Joann’s Fudge, and Ryba’s Fudge Shops. Each has its own twist on the classic treat. My personal favorite was the salted caramel fudge from Joann’s – the perfect balance of sweet and salty.
Pro Tip: Visit multiple shops for free samples and decide which one you like best before buying. Trust me, you’ll want to take some home!
Top 5 Restaurants You Can’t Miss
Mackinac Island has a surprisingly vibrant food scene. Here are my top picks:
- The Woods Restaurant – Hidden in the island’s interior, this Bavarian-style lodge offers an intimate, upscale dining experience. Their venison is a must-try.
- The Pink Pony – This was our favorite spot! A lively restaurant with live music, stunning harbor views, and known for the best whitefish dip on the island.
- Carriage House at Hotel Iroquois – Elegant dining with lakeside views. The crab cakes and fresh-caught whitefish are exceptional.
- The Yankee Rebel Tavern – Cozy and casual, with hearty comfort food.
- Mission Point Resort’s Round Island Bar & Grill – Perfect for a laid-back meal with breathtaking sunset views over the lake. Their burgers are fantastic.
Pro Tip: Make reservations in advance, especially for The Woods and The Pink Pony, as they fill up quickly. Also, if you MUST have your daily Starbuck’s fix, there’s one of those too. Just be careful riding your bike with that hot coffee. 🙂
Final Thoughts: Why Mackinac Island Captured My Heart
Mackinac Island is a rare gem – a place where you can disconnect from the hustle and bustle of everyday life and immerse yourself in a simpler, slower pace. Whether you’re biking along the lakeshore, exploring historic forts, or indulging in yet another piece of fudge, the island offers a unique blend of history, adventure, and nostalgia.
If you’re looking for a memorable getaway that feels worlds away from the modern era, Mackinac Island is the perfect destination. I know I’ll be back someday – there’s just something about this place that keeps calling you back.